By Todd Anderson on Jan 25, 2018 at 9:00 AM
  1. Todd Anderson

    Todd Anderson News Editor / Reviewer/ Senior Admin
    Staff Member
    Thread Starter

    Joined:
    Jan 20, 2017
    Messages:
    3,483
    Likes Received:
    816
    Location:
    Balt/Wash Metro

    Monolith 12" THX Ultra Subwoofer Review

    Manufacturer & Model:
    Monoprice Monolith 12” THX Ultra Subwoofer
    MSRP:
    $799
    Link:
    https://www.monoprice.com/product?p_id=24457
    Highlights:
    Competitively priced, in-room performance below 20Hz, dual tunable ports, THX Ultra certification, tight and punchy output, excellent entry into high-end bass performance, edgy eye-catching styling.
    Summary:
    The Monolith 12” THX Ultra Subwoofer is one of three new THX certified Monolith subs designed to offer high-end performance without a hefty price tag. Overall build quality is impressive, as is the size of the subwoofer, which weighs nearly 100-lbs. The rear plate amp offers an impressive array of controls and connectivity options, while dual front firing ports are tunable via included foam plugs. Sound quality is excellent, featuring tight and powerful in-room performance that hits well below 20Hz, making the Monolith 12” THX Ultra a shortlist worthy subwoofer.
    [​IMG]


    Monoprice couldn’t help itself. First, it successfully became the Internet’s go to source for reasonably priced AV cables and interconnects. Now, it’s attempting to crack the foundation of a rather insulated top-end AV marketplace with seductively disruptive gear that’s priced right. Today, we’re shining a spotlight on the company’s brand-new Monolith 12” THX Ultra Subwoofer, a ridiculously fun subsonic cannon that offers head-turning performance for a mere $799 (plus shipping).


    Monolith Has Arrived
    [​IMG]

    If you’re not familiar with Monoprice’s relatively new Monolith badge, then it’s time to take notice. The company is actively leveraging healthy sales of its widely varied Monoprice branded products to deliver a range of audio gear – from headphones and speakers to amps and DACs – loaded to the brim with design elements typically found on products costing 20- to 40-percent more. The name of the game is high-performance and cost consciousness – and from my exposure (including in-home experience) with several Monolith products, Monoprice is poised to give the competition fits by servicing price savvy buyers that want more than just budget gear.

    Monoprice’s three new ported Monolith subwoofers (featuring single 10”, 12”, and 15” drivers) were officially announced just months ago at CEDIA 2017, with final labeling awaiting approval from the labs of THX. The original hope, according to Monoprice’s Hobie Sechrest (Senior Product Manager, Monolith), was for the 12” design to receive a THX Select rating. Instead, the hefty middle model was anointed THX Ultra status, independently establishing itself as performance ready for rooms up to 3,000 cubic feet. Combine that kind of rating with a sub-$800 price tag, and it’s entirely impossible not to be curious about the 12” THX Ultra subwoofer’s true real-world performance capabilities.


    The Guts Of Glory
    [​IMG]

    (Monoprice)

    The 12” THX Ultra subwoofer (along with its 10” THX Select and 15” THX Ultra brethren) has been percolating in Monoprice’s labs for the last several years, during which significant R&D capital was spent fine tuning the “guts and engineering” of the sub. According to Sechrest, Monoprice wanted to ensure top-line performance capabilities first and foremost (which, in the case of the 12” THX Ultra, equates to clean in-room performance hitting well below 20Hz).

    The man behind the curtain, so to speak, is a Claridy 500 Watts RMS (900 Watts peak) Class D amplifier managed by a Texas Instruments 48-bit DSP engine. The exterior of the amp features multiple controls, including Crossover, Phase, Gain, EQ (THX vs. Extended), and Power (On vs. Auto). It also houses an informative multi-color LED light that indicates the sub’s operational status. Connectivity wise, users have access to dual unbalanced RCA inputs along with single XLR balanced input and pass-through ports.

    [​IMG]

    The sub’s custom front-firing driver looks impressive, stamped dead-center with a Monolith logo and sporting a rather substantial surround formulated by NBR (Nitrile Rubber-acrylonitrile-butadiene copolymer). The “hybrid” high-excursion cone (>80mm peak-to-peak) is comprised of long fiber pulp and fiberglass for lightweight action while maintaining overall stiffness. And the motor structure is beefy to the eye, featuring a 60mm voice coil and a 9-lb magnet aided by spider and cone venting that lends to advanced cooling and reduced distortion.

    Overall output is tunable via dual front mounted 3.5” ports. The port mouths are flared with smooth black plastic surfaces. Monolith ships the sub with two firm foam plugs that measure 3.75” T x 3.75” W. Both are easy to insert and remove.


    Out Of The Box
    [​IMG]

    Monoprice’s subwoofer packaging experience is a mixture of both good and bad, with a strong emphasis on good. The sub arrived double boxed using double wall corrugated cardboard; the interior box was reasonably protected from its journey across the country. Internally, thick custom foam blocks and black cloth sacks more than adequately protected the sub, its grille, and the included power cord (a physical manual isn’t provided). That’s the good. The bad is a lack of any kind of unboxing instructions (which are typically included with gear weighing in the 100-lb range). That led to a guessing game consisting of flipping, sliding, and hoping my way to revealing the sub. Through the magic of film, the unboxing (video link below) looks rather easy, but I’m inclined to mention that I had several moments of stalled frustration. Of course, the experience didn’t present anything unsurmountable, but Monoprice should consider adding printed or on-box instructions as the Monolith line matures. Editor’s Note: Monoprice appreciates the feedback and says it will consider options for future packaging.

    Click on the video below to watch the entire unboxing process.



    The Monolith 12” THX Ultra subwoofer is a beast in the hands, weighing a smidge less than 100-lbs, and looks great to the eye with sharp lines and a unique edgy styling. Its 22.8” T x 16.7” W x 23.6” D HDF cabinet passes the knuckle wrap test with flying colors and truly handles like a brick. The exterior is covered in a low-sheen Black Ash high-grade vinyl that has the general appearance of wood veneer – it’s quite impressive. Overall fit and finish is spot-on, with excellent craftsmanship (yes, even the back side of the cloth grille is clean and well put together). As for exterior durability, my assumption is the 12” THX Ultra’s cabinet is perfectly fine for home theater duty (i.e., unbox and place), but that more frequent handling should be done with care.

    [​IMG]

    [​IMG]

    The plate amp’s knobs all turn with a gratifying smoothness paired with a pleasant amount of resistance, switches are crisp, and the grille cover (including its ¾” standoffs) fits firmly in the cabinet’s strategically placed grille mounting points. Again, considering price, Monoprice has given the 12” THX Ultra some nice little touches that elevate the user experience when interacting with the speaker. Color me impressed.


    Set Up
    [​IMG]

    Moving the Monolith 12” THX Ultra into place was a two-person operation, largely due to its weight and overall length. It was placed in a carpeted 2000-cubic foot dedicated home theater room at the front wall’s left quarter-point. The sub’s small rubber feet seemed to provide decent stability on the carpet, but are probably best suited for hard surfaces.

    Following roughly 30-hours of break-in, the sub was equalized with Audyssey MultEQ XT32 via a Marantz SR7012 AVR and paired with a 7.x.4 arrangement comprised of SVS Ultra and Prime Elevation speakers (system wide crossover = 80Hz). Other associated gear included an OPPO UDP-205 4K Blu-ray player, an Emotiva XPA5 amp, and – integrated later in the review – a Yamaha RX-A3050 AVR.

    Final subwoofer settings were as follows: Gain +0dB, Phase 0°, and THX EQ engaged. THX EQ asks the sub to perform within THX certification parameters, while the Extended mode is designed for slightly louder output with a minute uptick in distortion (Monoprice says measurable distortion in Extended mode remains within an inaudible threshold). My Room EQ Wizard (REW) measurements didn’t show a significant in-room performance difference between the two modes (response wise), hence I chose to leave THX EQ engaged.

    [​IMG]
    Post-calibration in-room measurements: Purple = Sealed, Blue = Two Ports, Green = One Port

    Following a variety of listening tests and frequency response measurements, I opted to run the sub with one port open. As you can see in the figure below, in-room output for both sealed and single port open modes of operation was excellent, digging deep into infrasonic frequencies. And I felt the one port open mode sounded tight and controlled, with more apparent depth and impact.

    It’s worthy to note that I – purely through personal choice – opted to run the 12” THX Ultra subwoofer cooked slightly hot (channel leveled at 79dB vs 75dB for other speakers in the system), but also experimented with dialing back the sub's output. Overall, I had zero complaints about system blending.


    The Sound
    [​IMG]

    (Lionsgate Films)

    Question: If someone handed you a bazooka at a proving ground, would you (A) fire it at a cardboard cutout of a pine tree, or (B) take aim at a scrapped military tank loaded with TNT? If you consider “B” to be the obvious answer, pat yourself on the back and hop into my world. The Monolith 12” subwoofer, you see, is a bazooka and I had no choice but to immediately fire it at the biggest target I could find. In review terms that means Blu-ray movies, specifically movies laced with devastating bass widely celebrated to hit low and hard.

    As I combed through my media library, I selected three films capable of challenging the 12” THX Ultra’s prowess: Edge of Tomorrow (Blu-ray), Deepwater Horizon (4K UHD Blu-ray), and Interstellar (4K UHD Blu-ray). And because I wanted immediate results, Edge of Tomorrow was the first disc to spin.

    Edge of Tomorrow’s Blu-ray release is legendary for its first scene bass attack that cycles through several brutal subsonic and infrasonic tones. If you’re unfamiliar with the opening sequence, approach it cautiously. It can cripple less than capable gear. Being responsible, I kept close tabs on the volume control, easing the 12” THX Ultra into the Edge of Tomorrow’s challenging waters. I quickly found no hand-holding was necessary, as the sub confidently dished-out punishing bass without any hint of unpleasantry. I pushed output levels to near reference, and the sub didn’t flinch, filling my dedicated room with pulsating bass (yes, even the opening scene’s 10Hz thunder). The remainder of the film was a delightful listen, layered with tight and nuanced LFE that graced the audio presentation with a weighty texture and impact. Everything from the subtle rumble of aircraft engines to the powerful thuds of explosions and falling debris was present and devoid of bloated or loose playback. And the smaller impacts of bass bursts associated with weapons firing were quick and tight.

    Suffice to say, the 12” THX Ultra passed its first challenge.

    Phase two of the evaluation introduced more explosions, this time at the hands of Deepwater Horizon. Deepwater is loaded with a variety of LFE, including tension building pulsations that match the intensity of the film’s storyline, and the 12” THX Ultra obliged with a buttery smooth presentation. The sub’s transient capabilities were on full display during the crews’ helicopter ride to the oil platform, as sound associated with the copter’s blades was tight and textured. But the beef of the film’s bass is paired with the Gulf’s cracking seafloor and the resulting explosive chaos that occurs on the surface of the water. The 12” THX Ultra didn’t disappoint. The sub injected powerful rumbles into my theater room – shaking seating – as the Horizon was lost. I even noted subtle bass drops that floated with controlled character. From start to finish, I was thoroughly impressed as the 12” THX Ultra met the film’s demands with thunderous composure.

    My experience with Interstellar was much the same, with notable performance output experienced during the film’s incredibly challenging big bass moments (namely the worm hole and black hole scenes). The 12” THX Ultra kept pace with grace, never showing signs of wilting under pressure as volumes were advanced to reference levels. Most importantly, the resulting bass maintained character, devoid of any bloated or loose output that you might expect from an inferior party-pounder.

    [​IMG]
    (Jon Bellion / Capitol Records)

    Moving onto music, I re-experimented with various port tunings and – once again – confirmed a preference for operating with one port open. After thrashing my theater room with hard-hitting film content, I was eager to explore the 12” THX Ultra’s musical capabilities. First, I took a journey into Thundercat’s bizarre world of Drunk (TIDAL). Musical tastes aside, Thundercat’s bass guitar exposé and kick drum beats make for great sub demo material. “Captain Stupido” sounded phenomenal, loaded with quick bass notes that blended perfectly with my system’s Ultra Tower mains. The character of Thundercat’s bass guitar was high-level in its presentation. And the tightness of bass in “A Fan’s Mail” was rich and pleasing to the ear. As eluded to earlier, the 12” THX Ultra’s output fell in line with what I’d expect from well-regarded gear.

    Next up was Jon Bellion’s Human Condition (CD), an album layered with low-end fun that likes to run smooth and long. Shorter bursts of bass heard during “80’s films” were tight and punctuated, and the song’s subtle background bass drops maintained clean character as they fell into the lower depths of hearing. A very similar low-end experience graced Bellion’s “Overwhelming,” which has plenty of pop that hits tight and then smoothly slides away. The 12” THX Ultra kept pace, once again relying on its ability to punch without looseness. This particular track allowed the sub’s confident musicality to shine right to reference volume levels.

    One final audio test came at the hands of an old-time favorite that makes for fantastic demo material: Meat Beat Manifesto’s Now EP (CD). This rare audio gem is loaded to the brim with raw and punishing electronic bass that’s repetitive and unrelenting. The EP’s second remix track, “Paradise Found,” opens with a heartbeat-like bassline that bleeds into a mesmerizing drum beat. The 12” THX Ultra delivered pure and tight bass with composure right to reference levels and beyond. The EP's third track, “Paradise Now,” contains an equally punishing bass guitar rhythm that also played cleanly right to reference. Again, these are incredibly challenging audio tracks that present brutal bass expectations at high volume levels. It was a pure power show of super tight and explosive bass. In fact, during later testing sessions involving these songs, the bass output dislodged a glass candle holder and a framed mirror (in an adjacent room) from their resting places and sent them crashing to the floor.

    The Monolith 12” THX Ultra is a beast after all.


    Conclusion
    [​IMG]

    The Monolith 12” THX Ultra subwoofer is a super intriguing entry on numerous levels, and Monoprice deserves a high-five for bringing such high caliber performance to market at a budget friendly price point. For $799, an enthusiast can fetch nearly 100-lbs of sub with an amp/driver combination that produces high-level bass output. Forget raw and boomy power, the 12” THX Ultra has the composure of high-class gear. It can punch and lower the boom with a clarity and powerful tightness that allows for natural and controlled playback, all the while fully carrying the load of a system’s low-end output. Add to that three possible variations of port tunings, and the sub presents quite a bit of room-friendly flexibility. This is definitely a sub worthy of shortlist status – cost-conscious buyers take note, the 12” THX Ultra is your gateway to serious home theater performance.


    [​IMG]
    Monolith 12" THX Ultra Subwoofer Specifications
    • Model: 24457
    • Woofer: 12" cone
    • Cone Material: 2 layer long fiber pulp/glass fiber cone
    • Voice Coil: 60mm with high temperature aluminum wire and black anodized aluminum bobbin
    • Surround: FEA optimized NBR (nitrile budadiene rubber)
    • Motor: FEA optimized, 2 aluminum shorting rings, undercut T-pole focused field
    • Magnet: Ceramic Y35, 2 pcs total 144 oz.
    • Xmax: 18mm (one-way)
    • Xmech: 80mm (peak-to-peak)
    • Enclosure: Sealed or vented HDF cabinet with horizontal and vertical bracing
    • Finish: Black Ash
    • Amplifier: Class D 500Wrms
    • Frequency Response: (-6dB) Sealed Vented (1 port) Vented (2 ports)
    • Extended EQ: 26-200Hz 19-200Hz 18-200Hz
    • THX EQ: 29-200Hz 23-200Hz 20-200Hz
    • Harmonic Distortion: <1% 20-100Hz (90dB @ 1m)
    • Variable Level Control: +15/-20dB
    • Crossover: Inline/Bypass variable 40-160Hz
    • Inputs: RCA (2), XLR
    • Outputs: XLR
    • Signal Turn On: Selectable always on/auto
    • Auto Turn Off: 30 minutes
    • Dimensions: (H x W x D) 22.8" x 16.7" x 23.6" (580 x 425 x 600mm)
    • Net Weight: 98.5 lbs. (44.7 kg)
    • Gross Weight: 125.7 lbs. (57 kg)
     
    BD55 and tripplej like this.

Comments

Discussion in 'AV Equipment Reviews' started by Todd Anderson, Jan 25, 2018.

    1. Todd Anderson

      Todd Anderson News Editor / Reviewer/ Senior Admin
      Staff Member
      Thread Starter

      Joined:
      Jan 20, 2017
      Messages:
      3,483
      Likes Received:
      816
      Location:
      Balt/Wash Metro

      2000 cu ft room... the lowest output was in sealed and one port open modes. Not sure about overall port tuning...
       
    2. Todd Anderson

      Todd Anderson News Editor / Reviewer/ Senior Admin
      Staff Member
      Thread Starter

      Joined:
      Jan 20, 2017
      Messages:
      3,483
      Likes Received:
      816
      Location:
      Balt/Wash Metro
      Meaning split as in using both outputs from the AVR?
       
    3. Asere

      Asere AV Addict

      Joined:
      Apr 14, 2017
      Messages:
      571
      Likes Received:
      104
      Meaning using one output from the AVR with a Y splitter to combine the subs.
      They will be stacked as designed. That way if the avr sees them as one it should provide more headroom.
       
    4. tesseract

      tesseract Senior Admin
      Staff Member

      Joined:
      Nov 12, 2016
      Messages:
      773
      Likes Received:
      151
      Location:
      Lincoln, NE
      Are you sure it is the cabinet and not the room? Please, feel free to start a thread in the Subwoofer section so we can get down to the nitty gritty and figure this out for you.
       
    5. Asere

      Asere AV Addict

      Joined:
      Apr 14, 2017
      Messages:
      571
      Likes Received:
      104
      Well I just checked the light for clipping and it's solid green with really low content. I then felt the driver and moves really fast but not over extending. Lastly I walked around the room and yes it's structure not the sub. (I'm slapping myself) I should know the KK's are better performers then that lol.
      Now back to the Monolith talk and again my apologies for going off subject here.
      Thanks guys!
       
      Todd Anderson likes this.
    6. Todd Anderson

      Todd Anderson News Editor / Reviewer/ Senior Admin
      Staff Member
      Thread Starter

      Joined:
      Jan 20, 2017
      Messages:
      3,483
      Likes Received:
      816
      Location:
      Balt/Wash Metro
      You'll definitely have more headroom just as a function of turning gain down when you go dual...
       
      Asere likes this.
    7. Ralph Potts

      Ralph Potts New Member

      Joined:
      Jan 31, 2018
      Messages:
      9
      Likes Received:
      4
      Greetings,

      Nice review @Todd Anderson. The Monolith subs are interesting, and a great choice for enthusiasts that aren't looking to break the bank. :T


      Regards,
       
      Todd Anderson likes this.
    8. Todd Anderson

      Todd Anderson News Editor / Reviewer/ Senior Admin
      Staff Member
      Thread Starter

      Joined:
      Jan 20, 2017
      Messages:
      3,483
      Likes Received:
      816
      Location:
      Balt/Wash Metro
    9. Deuce

      Deuce New Member

      Joined:
      May 3, 2018
      Messages:
      4
      Likes Received:
      0
      I have the ten inch version and while I am not playing organ music, it sounds great ....but i have a 2500 cu foot room and am going to add a second one. At $500 each, able to move easily to dial in right room placement, and better WAF, readers shoudl eriosuly consider these- I regard this as the real ground breaker in new Monolith sub Line.
       
    10. Matthew J Poes

      Matthew J Poes Staff Writer
      Staff Member

      Joined:
      Oct 18, 2017
      Messages:
      1,120
      Likes Received:
      171
      They are a really great value. I helped a friend do the CEA-2010 testing on both the ten and twelve for his magazine. It’s impressive what kind of output is possible from these subs. The components and enclosure are exceptional for the money. The only line of subs I know to be similar for the money is the SVS 2000 series, and these have some advantages, including a bit more output at very low frequencies.

      One thing that surprised us during testing was that the 10” didn’t scale with the 12” in output. We expected that the amplifier power and displacement would be such that the smaller driver would be about 3dB short of the 12 at each frequency. It turned out that in order to get a ten that could put out that kind of low bass, more compromises were made in the midbass and so it was lower output than anticipated in the midbass. What we found was that the typical rule that two of the tens would equal the twelve wasn’t quite true. The ten is much easier to manage physically and it’s deep bass is impressive for a ten. However If you have a larger space i would go with the 12 or 15. You would actually need 3 of the tens to equal just one of the 12’s. The difference in output was 107dB vs 112dB at most midbass frequencies with a similar advantage below 30hz. However below 30hz that ten has mor clean output than nearly anything it’s size on the market.

      The strict thx requirements also have led to subwoofers with substantially less distortion than we see from comparable brands. It appears to be as much based on the limiters and dsp processing as it is on special design. You can turn off the THX mode and it raised output a few dB at the expense of more distortion.
       

Share This Page