Do you think the march to more channels in surround sound is slowing down?

3dbinCanada

Moderator
Staff member
Thread Starter
Joined
Dec 29, 2020
Messages
893
More  
Preamp, Processor or Receiver
Yamaha RX-A3060, RX-V1900, RX-V1075
Universal / Blu-ray / CD Player
Yamaha BD-S681, Sony UBP-X800, Oppo BDP-83
Front Speakers
PSB Image T65, PSB Century 800, PSB Century 300
Center Channel Speaker
PSB Image 8C, PSB Century200, PSB Century 100
Surround Speakers
PSB Image 1B, RBH A600, PSB Alpha Minis
Surround Back Speakers
PSB Image 1B
Subwoofers
Rythmik LV12-R, PSB Subsonic 6, PSB Subsonic 5
Video Display Device
UN65KU6491 65"/UN55MU7000 55"/UN50MU7100 50"
Remote Control
Logitech Harmony 650
Streaming Equipment
BlueSound Node2i
Is there going to be a point where the number of audio channels being made available will no longer enhance the surround sound experience and be just plain over kill? Will marketing hype prevail over science in this regard?
 

Sonnie

Senior Admin
Staff member
Joined
Apr 2, 2017
Messages
5,223
Location
Alabama
More  
Preamp, Processor or Receiver
StormAudio ISP Elite 24 MK3 Processor
Main Amp
McIntosh MC1.25KW Monoblock Amps
Additional Amp
StormAudio PA 16 MK3
Computer Audio
Intel NUC w/ Roon ROCK
Universal / Blu-ray / CD Player
Panasonic UB9000 4K UHD Player (for media discs)
Front Speakers
RTJ 410
Center Channel Speaker
MartinLogan Focus C-18
Front Wide Speakers
JTR Neosis 110HT
Surround Speakers
JTR Neosis 210RT
Surround Back Speakers
JTR Neosis 210RT
Front Height Speakers
JTR Neosis 110HT-SL
Rear Height Speakers
JTR Neosis 110HT-SL
Subwoofers
JTR Captivator 2400 x6
Other Speakers or Equipment
VTI Amp Stands for the Monoblocks
Video Display Device
Sony 98X90L
Remote Control
Universal MX-890
Streaming Equipment
Kaleidescape | FireCube | Lenova X1 - Intel NUC for Roon
Streaming Subscriptions
Lifetime Roon Subscription
Tidal
qobuz
Netflix
Amazon Prime
Satellite System
Dish Joey 4K
Other Equipment
Zero Surge 8R15W-1 | Salamander Synergy Equipment Stand
I think they could keep adding channels in an effort to make the surround more seamless between speakers, but then again, they can use various technologies (maybe something like phase shifting) to fill the gap distances between speakers, too. The question might be how far someone is willing to go with it... do you want to keep adding speakers and amp channels, and then who is going to produce the processing.
 

Aburguy

Moderator
Staff member
Joined
Jul 15, 2023
Messages
82
Location
Ontario, Canada
More  
Preamp, Processor or Receiver
Anthem MrX1140
Universal / Blu-ray / CD Player
Panasonic 820
Front Speakers
Golden Ear Triton 5
Center Channel Speaker
Golden Ear Super Center XL
Surround Speakers
Golden Ear Aon 2
Front Height Speakers
Golden Ear Super Sat 3
Rear Height Speakers
Golden Ear Super Sat 3
Subwoofers
Golden Ear ForceField 3 (2)
Video Display Device
Sony A80-K 77
Remote Control
Sofa Baton X1
Streaming Subscriptions
Disney, Netflix, Prime, Apple TV+
Other Equipment
Apple TV 4K 2022, Hue Playlights
I wonder about this as well. I currently and running surrounds and have thought have adding rears, but I’m pretty satisfied with the current sound, and if I add rears I may have to move everything around. Not that I don’t want to do the work but if I only get incremental gain, I don’t think it’s worth the effort or cost.
 

JStewart

Senior AV Addict
Supporter
Joined
Dec 5, 2017
Messages
2,086
Location
Central FL
Unless it’s proven otherwise since, a 2007 study cited on and around page 350 of Dr. Toole’s book “Sound Reproduction: The Acoustics and Psychoacoustics of Loudspeakers and Rooms, 3rd Edition” , clearly shows no statistical preference for 12 speakers vs 5 speakers in the current Dolby 5.1 recommended locations.

To be fair, it does not study speaker locations that are not in the horizontal plane.

Also, I think you make a fair point too, @Sonnie , that more speakers could be filling in gaps in the sound field. However some of that could be to make up for less than ideal speaker placement or room acoustics. Regardless, if it’s a solution to a problem then that’s fine, so long as wall call it what it is without a blanket statement of more is better.

From my own situation, I noticed very little difference in going from 5.1 to 7.1. And TBH, there’s not a ton of difference in the sound field with or without atmos. It’s impossible for enthusiasts to make valid comparisons though as the mix and/or streaming compression can be different and our auditory memory short and unreliable.

So, for me personally, unless there is some kind of actual evidence provided from a respected source and not from a company with financial gain on the line, my funds are staying put, march or no march.
 

Sonnie

Senior Admin
Staff member
Joined
Apr 2, 2017
Messages
5,223
Location
Alabama
More  
Preamp, Processor or Receiver
StormAudio ISP Elite 24 MK3 Processor
Main Amp
McIntosh MC1.25KW Monoblock Amps
Additional Amp
StormAudio PA 16 MK3
Computer Audio
Intel NUC w/ Roon ROCK
Universal / Blu-ray / CD Player
Panasonic UB9000 4K UHD Player (for media discs)
Front Speakers
RTJ 410
Center Channel Speaker
MartinLogan Focus C-18
Front Wide Speakers
JTR Neosis 110HT
Surround Speakers
JTR Neosis 210RT
Surround Back Speakers
JTR Neosis 210RT
Front Height Speakers
JTR Neosis 110HT-SL
Rear Height Speakers
JTR Neosis 110HT-SL
Subwoofers
JTR Captivator 2400 x6
Other Speakers or Equipment
VTI Amp Stands for the Monoblocks
Video Display Device
Sony 98X90L
Remote Control
Universal MX-890
Streaming Equipment
Kaleidescape | FireCube | Lenova X1 - Intel NUC for Roon
Streaming Subscriptions
Lifetime Roon Subscription
Tidal
qobuz
Netflix
Amazon Prime
Satellite System
Dish Joey 4K
Other Equipment
Zero Surge 8R15W-1 | Salamander Synergy Equipment Stand
I bucked the system (so to speak) for many years, refusing to budge from a 5 channel surround. I finally did go to 7 channels and eventually 9 channels, but I can't say I have noticed a great difference... maybe some difference. Now that I'm at 9.6.4 with Atmos, I have yet to be blown away by any Atmos movie or music. It all just seems very subtle, but nothing startling or overwhelming, which maybe that is how it should be. Nonetheless... I could probably be just as happy with the 5-channel surround as I am with Atmos, yet I plan to go to 9.6.6 as soon as my other JTR speakers arrive.
 
  • Like
Reactions: VJM

Mike Schramm

Moderator
Staff member
Bright Side Crew
Joined
Sep 18, 2019
Messages
371
Location
Minooka, Illinois
More  
Preamp, Processor or Receiver
Onkyo TX-RZ840
Main Amp
Emotiva BasX A7
Universal / Blu-ray / CD Player
Panasonic DP-UB820
Front Speakers
SVS Ultra Bookshelves
Center Channel Speaker
SVS Ultra Center
Surround Speakers
SVS Prime Satellites
Surround Back Speakers
SVS Prime Satellites
Front Height Speakers
SVS Prime Satellites
Rear Height Speakers
SVS Prime Satellites
Subwoofers
SVS PB-2000 Pro (x2)
Other Speakers or Equipment
miniDSP 2x4 HD
Video Display Device
Sony XR-77A80J
Remote Control
Logitech Harmony One
Streaming Equipment
Apple 4K
Streaming Subscriptions
Netflix, Hulu, Apple Music, Amazon Prime
Doesn't it come down to trying to accommodate more and more people in your theater? If it's just one person sitting in the sweet spot between two speakers (and a sub) in a properly treated room isn't it possible to have a surround sound experience? I've never experienced this myself but I have heard others say that it can be done.
 
  • Like
Reactions: VJM

Sonnie

Senior Admin
Staff member
Joined
Apr 2, 2017
Messages
5,223
Location
Alabama
More  
Preamp, Processor or Receiver
StormAudio ISP Elite 24 MK3 Processor
Main Amp
McIntosh MC1.25KW Monoblock Amps
Additional Amp
StormAudio PA 16 MK3
Computer Audio
Intel NUC w/ Roon ROCK
Universal / Blu-ray / CD Player
Panasonic UB9000 4K UHD Player (for media discs)
Front Speakers
RTJ 410
Center Channel Speaker
MartinLogan Focus C-18
Front Wide Speakers
JTR Neosis 110HT
Surround Speakers
JTR Neosis 210RT
Surround Back Speakers
JTR Neosis 210RT
Front Height Speakers
JTR Neosis 110HT-SL
Rear Height Speakers
JTR Neosis 110HT-SL
Subwoofers
JTR Captivator 2400 x6
Other Speakers or Equipment
VTI Amp Stands for the Monoblocks
Video Display Device
Sony 98X90L
Remote Control
Universal MX-890
Streaming Equipment
Kaleidescape | FireCube | Lenova X1 - Intel NUC for Roon
Streaming Subscriptions
Lifetime Roon Subscription
Tidal
qobuz
Netflix
Amazon Prime
Satellite System
Dish Joey 4K
Other Equipment
Zero Surge 8R15W-1 | Salamander Synergy Equipment Stand
That's a good point, Mike. I suppose if you have several rows of seats, more speakers might make sense and help appropriate the surround better.
 

Peter Loeser

Moderator
Staff member
Joined
Apr 23, 2017
Messages
259
Location
Southwest Michigan
IMO the availability of consumer 32-channel home theater processors brings us to the point of diminishing returns. Large scale cinemas demand more as stated, but more so to provide a consistent experience to all seat locations.

As Mike mentioned, achieving the sweet spot in a stereo setup can produce a shockingly immense sound stage, but isn’t practical for most people.

Going forward I’d say the most bang for buck will be continued advancement of digital picture quality. I believe that will be more perceptible to enthusiast and even average viewers. Video will reach the point of diminishing returns eventually too. Then… I don’t know, maybe holographs?
 

Travis Ballstadt

Administrator
Staff member
Joined
Jul 26, 2017
Messages
1,148
Location
Seattle, WA
More  
Preamp, Processor or Receiver
Anthem AVM60
Main Amp
Emotiva BasX 5
Additional Amp
Emotiva UPA-500
Universal / Blu-ray / CD Player
Kaleidescape Strato C/Terra 48TB/Compact Terra 6TB
Front Speakers
NextLevel Acoustics Reference Cinema
Center Channel Speaker
NextLevel Acoustics Reference Cinema
Surround Speakers
NextLevel Acoustics Reference Cinema
Front Height Speakers
NextLevel Acoustics Angled Satellite
Rear Height Speakers
NextLevel Acoustics Angled Satellite
Subwoofers
SVS SB2000 x2
Video Display Device
JVC DLA X790R, Lumagen Radiance Pro 4240
Screen
SeymourAV Proscenium 124” diagonal 2.40:1
Remote Control
Unfolded Circle Remote 2, powered by HomeAssistant
Streaming Equipment
PLEX Server, AppleTV4K, Bluesound Node2i
Streaming Subscriptions
AppleTV+, Amazon Prime, HBO Max
Satellite System
They still have those?
Other Equipment
Rega Planar 6, Rega Exact2 cart, Rega Aria Mk3 Phono Stage, Jolida JD202BRC, Rega RS-5 Speakers (2-channel system)
Seems like the whole controversy a couple years ago where studios/dolby were preventing any processing from upmixing beyond 7.1.4 really cooled demand from the consumers.

I think logically the push should be more towards more use of objects and more object capability in the home setting and allowing processing to generate as many channels as the user wants to pay for would be the best use of resources. Objects being so much more scalable than channels makes it as future-proof as it could theoretically be, and something that could maximize every home theater regardless of size, shape, configuration or budget.
 
Top Bottom